Differential Manometers

Problem #84

Tags: engineering physics instructional

Who solved this?

Previous:Heat Flow through Dissimilar Materials Next:Pressurized Fluid Flow


Most of us have an intuitive understanding of Fluid Pressure. We blow air into tires and they become hard with pressure. If we blow up a balloon too much it will pop from the pressure. We may have also seen videos where balloons will expand continuously and pop once reaching the upper atmosphere, or that compressible items will shrink when brought deep beneath the ocean.

The ambient air around us works similarly, constantly pressing on us from all directions at all times. The reason why balloons expand continuously and pop when the atmosphere gets thin is because there is not enough air pressure oustide the walls of the balloon pushing back against the air pressurizing the inside of the balloon.

In some facilities where cleanliness is a critical factor (such as hospitals) the air inside the building is kept slightly pressurized compared to outside, to encourage dust and dirt to blow outside when doors are opened. What if we wanted to create a simple device that we can look at to quickly determine if the pressure inside the building is greater or less than outside the building? It turns out that we could make such a device called a Differential Manometer, using just a bent tube and some fluid.

A model of a differential manometer

A U-Bend Differential Manometer.
Here the pressure P_B is greater than P_A, causing h_B to be less than h_A.

Let's imagine we have some cylindrical tube in the shape of a U-bend which is open on both ends, and inside we pour some liquid (like water) which completely covers the bend. We then place this tube inside the wall of our building so that one end is inside and the other end is outside. Initially when the internal Building Pressure P_B and the Atmospheric Pressure P_A outside the building are equal, the fluid levels in both straight sections of the tube inside and outside the building are at the same height. However after the building begins to pressurize itself, P_B will increase while P_A stays constant. Observing the tube, we would expect the fluid level height in the "inside" section of the tube to decrease, while the fluid level height in the "outside" section of the tube to increase. But why does that happen?

First we should recognize that Pressure is a Force applied to an Area. We can have an intuitive sense of this because it "pushes" on things. In the same manner Weight can also be understood as a Force, as heavy objects push downwards on whatever is beneath them. We can calculate this force of weight with the equation F = m * a, where F is the force of weight, m is the mass of the object, and a is the acceleration (in this case, the acceleration due to gravity g ~= -9.8 m/s^2).

In our example, lets define some height near the bottom of the manometer (but still within the constant-radius sections of the straight tubes) as h = 0. For each of the little slices of fluid in the cross-sectional area of each straight section, let's calculate the total force pushing downwards on each little area. Each total downward force is comprised of two forces - the force applied by the Ambient Pressure, and the force applied by the weight of the cylinder of fluid in that tube. Let's recall that we can calculate the mass of a cylinder given it's density ρ (called "rho"), multiplied by it's height h, multiplied again by it's cross-sectional area c. However when calculating the force over the cross-sectional area, c ends up dividing itself out. Therefore, the total downward force being applied on the cross-sectional area at h=0 on each side:

$$\huge F_A = P_A + \rho g h_A$$ $$\huge F_B = P_B + \rho g h_B$$

However, let's think about this for a moment. When a force is applied to an object then it causes that object to move, unless there is an equal force in the opposite direction to cancel it out. But in our example once both pressure's have stabilized, the fluid should not be moving! The magic here is that due to the bend in our manometer, any force which pushes the fluid downward on one side of the tube is actually also pushing the fluid in the other tube upwards, and so the fact that the fluid is stationary implies that F_A = F_B.

Problem Statement

Take a differential manometer like the one described above. Initially both inside and outside pressures are equal to P_A, and so both fluid levels are equal. The plan is to change the building's internal air to P_B. As the building's air pressure changes you watch the fluid level inside the building change as well. How far above or below will the fluid level change from the initial amount after the inside pressure has reached P_B, given density of the fluid ρ, and assuming that the external atmospheric pressure has stayed constant?

Also, we're using Imperial units for this problem:

Input Data
First line is Q, the quantity of testcases.
Q lines will then follow, each holding three space-separated decimal values: P_A, P_B, and ρ.

Answer
Should consist of Q space-separated values corresponding to distance that h_B has shifted. Report downward shifts as negative distances.
Error should be less than 1e-6.

Example

input data:
1
14.700 14.702 62.4

answer:
0.00086
You need to login to get test data and submit solution.